by Mishaco 11-24-2012
Barely a decade ago, a person could hardly walk into a gun shop, and not
put eyes on at least a few old communist pistols, chambered for the
9x18mm cartridge. Some were real Makarovs and others were not. Some came
in as new guns, while others as used military surplus. All though were
simple, reliable, little guns, steeped in 20th century design and
Today these pistols are encountered less and less often, especially the
earlier ones like the original PM and the unique PA-63. As a result,
they are also talked about less. Many of you may in fact only really be
aware of the Czech Vz.82, which has become a popular CCW piece in recent
years; but there are many old communist designs firing the snappy
little cartridge. It has been nearly 3 years since I have done any kind
of Makarov Thread, and that one wasn't very detailed or comprehensive
anyway. So feeling that I have ignored and neglected some of my longtime
favorite firearms for long enough, here we go....
"More Than You Ever Wanted To Know About The Soviet Makarov & Other 9x18mm Pistols"
History & Development:
In 1945, immediately after the end of the Great Patriotic War, the
General Staff of the Soviet Red Army announced it would be holding
trials to select a new standard issue service sidearm. Since the early
1930s, the Red Army had been equipped with both the Tokarev TT33
automatic and the older Nagant M1895 revolver. Both pistols were
durable, reliable, and inexpensive to produce, however each had its own
shortcomings and flaws. The new service pistol would need to fulfill
First it had to be an automatic/self-loading design, chambered for
either a 9mm or 7.65mm diameter bullet. Next, it had to be more compact
and more accurate than the TT33; while remaining at least as reliable,
durable, and easy to maintain in the field. It must have a manually
operated safety catch. As with Red Army firearms before it, the new
design would be best received if it used a minimum number of parts, was
easy to train soldiers with, and would be well suited for mass
production. The initial round of trials were held in 1947.
(A prototype Makarov built in 1947; picture from ModernFirearms.ru)
In 1949, after three years of planning and one-off prototypes, the
Izhevsk Mechanical FActory began limited production of a trials pistol
developed by Nikolay Fyodorovich Makarov. Makarov's design would later
be designated as the Pistolet Makarova, and I do not think it is a
spoiler to say that ultimately, it won the trials to become the new
Soviet issue firearm.
The PM pistol was a simple straight blow-back design with a double/single
action trigger, manual safety, and compact dimensions. It fired the
9x18mm cartridge, also designated as the 'PM' round. Both pistol and
cartridge were heavily influenced by pre-war Nazi German designs.
The pistol itself strongly resembled the Walther PP or PPK. It was
larger than the PPK, but had a shorter slide and barrel than the PP. It
used a similar double/single action trigger system, along with the same
style of slide mounted decocker safety. The PM even field stripped with
the same procedure as the PPK. Still, Makarov did make some noteworthy
changes to the original pattern. Generally speaking, he simplified the
design. The PM consisted of fewer parts than the PPK, and tolerances
were not required to be nearly as exacting and tight. The magazine
release was changed from a button type located on the upper left side of
the frame; to a latch type located on the heel of the grip. Though the
Walther did feature a last-round bolt hold open, it did not have an
external slide release lever. Makarov incorporated such a lever into his
own design. Like the Walther, the Makarov used a wrap-around bakelite
grip. However, the PM grip was made from a single piece, with a lanyard
staple on the left side. It was attached to the frame via a single
square shaped screw.
(A very early production PM manufactured in 1949; picture from ModernFirearms.ru)
The 9x18mm PM cartridge itself was developed by Syomin. It was based on a
pre-war 9x18mm experimental German cartridge, named '9mm Ultra.' The
idea behind both cartridges was to have the most powerful round
possible, which could safely be fired out of a straight-blowback system.
Both nations saw the system as possibly advantageous as it allowed for a
fixed barrel, which would be more inhereently accurate. It was also
more reliable and easier to manufacture. Both 9x18mm cartridges were
marginally more powerful than 9x17mm Kurz (9mm Short aka 9mm Browning,
aka .380 ACP), with the 9x18mm PM round being slightly more powerful
than 9x18mm Ultra. The 9x18mm PM bullet itself had an actual diameter of
9.2mm and was designed to be a short to medium range self-defense
round. At these ranges, it was actually more effective at imparting its
energy into a target than the older 7.62x25mm TT cartridge, which was a notorious over-penetrator. Postwar Soviet military doctrine recognized
that the personal sidearm was of limited value on the modern
battlefield. Its only real use was as a short range defensive weapon.
These attitudes greatly shaped the Makarov PM design.
The Actual Makarov PM & PMM Pistols:
(A 1971 standard issue Soviet Makarov; picture from ModernFirearms.ru)
(A standard military issue PM produced in Bulgaria in the 1980s.)
The Makarov PM was officially declared the winner of the Army trials in
1948 and the go-ahead was given to further refine and perfect the design
by the General Staff. Following several minor but important changes,
the PM entered into full-scale production at the Izhevsk factory in 1951.
However, the pistol was never given a very high priority in Soviet
Russia. It was perceived as a peacetime weapon with limited battlefield
utility. Instead, first the AK47 and later the AKM were given
importance. Soviet doctrine at the time did not even embrace the
traditional submachinegun; instead relying on so-called assault rifles.
Nevertheless, by the late 1950s, thousands of PM pistols were being
produced every year, with the numbers increasing throughout the
following decades. The pistol was so easy to produce and inexpensive,
that even with a low production priority enough PMs had been built by
the early 1960s, that they had mostly completely replaced older pistols
in the Red Army. Enough were available in fact, that starting in the
1960s, Russian militia (police) also began to be issued the new pistols.
The pistol was a masterpiece in simplicity and durability. It consisted
of only 27 parts, with most parts performing 2 or even 3 functions. It
was built of all steel, except for the single piece bakelite grip, so
there was little that could actually go wrong or break during normal
use. Initially the free floating firing pin was a cause of concern to
some, as they feared it could possibly lead to accidental discharges, in
the form of slam-fires. Makarov himself insisted this was unlikely,
pointing out that the light firing pin simply did not have enough mass
to set off a primer, unless struck by the pistol's hammer. In the end,
the firing pin gave few if any problems to its military and police
The PM remained virtually unaltered in design throughout its production
life, however the manufacturing techniques used to create some of its
parts were updated and modernized. Beginning in the late 1970s, some
parts which had previously been machined, started to be made from
investment castings. During the 1980s, some parts were further
simplified. For example, some Russian Makarovs were built with stamped
slide release levers. These changes made the pistols easier to
manufacture and assemble, as well as saving on resources.
(Another military issue PM; this one made in East Germany in 1960.)
The Makarov Pm was officially adopted by 12 nations, including Russia
itself. Most Russian PMs were built by izhevsk, with a smaller number by
Tula. It was manufactured in three other communist nations. Starting
around 1958, the Ernst Thaelmann Factory in East Germany (DDR) began
Makarov production, which lasted for many years. It was designated as
the Pistole.M by that nation's armed forces. Next, communist China
started making its own Type 59 Makarov pistols, which were exported
under the Norinco brand. Type 59 production lasted at least until the
1990s, and could possibly even be ongoing today. The last nation to
begin domestic Makarov manufacturing was Bulgaria, which didn't commence full-scale production until the late 1970s. Arsenal (BG) was the primary
production facility and the pistol was simply known as the PM by the
Bulgarian military and police. Bulgarian Makarov production seems to
have ended roughly around the turn of the millennium. Finally, some
Makarov pistols were built for export sales in post-Unification Germany,
during the 1990s. Under the Simson-Suhl name, a private company bought
up surplus parts and tooling from the former DDR state, and recommenced
PM production for a brief time. These pistols were basically identical
to earlier DDR PMs, except that they had a safety system which was
slightly modified. The new safety lever did not lock the slide when
engaged; allowing it to be retracted.
(A military/police PMM; picture from ModernFirearms.ru)
Revisiting the Makarov in Russia, in 1990 a team at Izhevsk released the
Pistolet Makarova Modifitsirovanny (Pistol Makarov Modified). The PMM
was an updated and somewhat modernized design, which was intended to
address some of the original PM's shortcomings. By the end of the 1980s,
the Soviet Army was starting to look towards replacing its solid, but
dated pistol. Izhevsk was hoping that the PMM would be an acceptable
update and replacement of the older design.
The PMM used the same trigger system, control layout, and field strip
procedure as the PM, so it was felt it would be quite easy to transition
soldiers over to the new model. It was also just as simple and durable
as before; however, rather than feeding from a single stack 8 round
magazine, the PMM could feed from newly developed 12 round double stack
magazines. This meant that the magazine well had to be widened, and thus
the grip too would be 'fatter.' An interesting feature of the new
design was that it could also feed reliably from original single stack
magazines, of which the Soviet Army had large stock piles. Because of
the grip's new dimensions, the lanyard staple had to be relocated from
the left side, to the rear base of the grip. The PMM retained the same
single piece grip though, still attached by a single screw.
The PMM also fired an updated cartridge, named 9x18mm PMM. This new
loading featured a lighter bullet and an increased powder charge.
Izhevsk claimed this combination could deliver up to 25% greater energy,
compared to the traditional 9x18mm PM loading. To insure reliable
extraction with the hotter round, the PMM's chamber was fluted. Even
with ammunition though, the new Makarov pistol was backwards compatible.
It was able to fire the standard PM cartridge reliably and safely.
Izhevsk designed the PMM to have some clear advantages over the PM, but
kept many of the same parts and made sure it was compatible with older
hardware. Unfortunately for the PMM and its developers, before extensive
trials could be held to select Russia's next standard issue sidearm,
the communist government fell in 1991. The new democratic Russian
government and military wanted to move away from traditional communist
symbols and technology, at least as far as was practical. So by the time
the Russian Federation Army was ready to continue the trials, it had
already decided to adopt a firearm capable of firing the NATO standard
9x19mm round. Also, while the PMM was an improvement over the PM, it
simply wasn't enough of one to warrant the expenses and time that would
have been required for its adoption. In the end, the modernized Makarov
would not be purchased by the Russian military. It only found limited
commercial success with some police agencies who had thousands of 9mm PM
rounds and spare parts, in Russia and other former communist nations.
It was also exported to the USA for a brief time in slightly modified
form, but the USA's 1994 Assault Weapons Ban greatly hurt the pistol's
(A commercial IJ70-18AH with PMM grips)
Starting in the 1980s and lasting through the 1990s, several variants of
the Makarov PM were offered by Russia for commercial sales, most
notably to the civilian shooting public in the USA. The IJ70 series (IJ
as a Latinised abbreviation of Izhevsk) was marketed under the IMEZ and
Baikal trademarks. All of the Russian commercial Makarovs imported into
the USA had adjustable target sights. These sights were added to the
pistols to qualify them as 'sporting' under the American 1968 GCA.
Pistols could either be chambered for the standard 9x18mm PM or the
9x17mm Short (.380) round. Most were of the standard configuration, but
several 'high capacity' double stack models in both calibers were also
imported. These double stack Makarovs borrowed heavily from the PMM
design. Prior to the enactment of the AWB in September of 1994, these
pistols came with 12 round magazines and afterward, with ones modified
to hold only 10 rounds. IJ70 production lasted for only a handful of
years and was over before the millennium.
The FEG RK-59, R-61, & PA-63 Series:
(An SMC-918, a commercial version of the R-61 police pistol)
The first nation to adopt a unique domestic handgun design, which was
chambered for the 9x18mm PM cartridge was that of Hungary. The Hungarian
factory of FEG has had a long history of manufacturing Walther type
pistols stretching back to the period immediately following World War
II. As an interesting side note, FEG became so efficient at making
simple blowback firearms, that when Carl Walther GMBH of Ulm, Germany
decided to release the PPK/e for the European market, it selected FEG to
be its official licensed production facility. Anyway, back to the
In the late 1940s, FEG began offering the M48, a near exact clone of the
Walther PP pistol. The M48 was chambered for the 7.65mm cartridge,
which was very popular with European police and even some militaries for
many decades. The pistol had both a steel slide and frame, along with a
PP style double/single action trigger and decocker safety lever. The
M48 was purchased in relatively large numbers by various Hungarian
After the Soviet Army adopted the Makarov PM pistol, many individuals in
both the Hungarian police and military became intrigued by its
cartridge, which was significantly more powerful than what the M48 was
chambered for. The police though, were not impressed by the Russian
pistol itself. They wanted something that was both smaller and lighter,
but that could still handle the zippy PM round.
In 1958, the national Hungarian police ordered FEG to develop a new
pistol. It was to be similar in design and layout to the M48, but
capable of safely firing the 9x18mm cartridge. It also needed to be
compact and lightweight for comfortable all-day carry. Given a rather
difficult order, FEG nevertheless prooved itself more than capable of
meeting its customers' needs.
In 1959, the first Hungarian pistols chambered for the PM cartridge were
sent to select police units for field testing and evaluation. The new
design was named the RK-59. It was only slightly larger than the Walther
PPK, with a 3.4" barrel, and held 6 rounds of ammunition. It featured a
PPK style magazine release and internal slide hold open. Its decocker
safety lever operated the same as the Walther's, however it had an
improved firing pin safety. Unless the trigger was fully pulled to the
rear, the firing pin was physically tilted out of alignment with the
hammer, making accidental discharges highly unlikely. Interestingly,
Walther itself would begin installing a very similar safety system in
its police pistols starting in the 1970s. The RK-59's most innovative
feature though was its frame. While the slide was made of blued steel,
the frame was made of an aluminum alloy, which was left in the white,
giving the pistol a two-tone look. The alloy frame allowed the RK to way
under 20 oz; quite light for a late 1950s handgun. It used dual flat
checkered grip panels, made of plastic, which were very slim. Initially,
the new pistol was very well received by the police. It met or exceeded
all of their requirements. It was very compact, easy to carry and
conceal, and as powerful as a small handgun could realistically be
expected to be. However, it had one very serious design flaw.
The RK-59's ultra-modern (for its time), frame was made almost
exclusively of aluminum. While it was certainly much lighter than
steel, it simply was not nearly as durable. It was soon discovered that
the pistol had a relatively short service life. After a few thousand
rounds had been fired through the pistol, the frame would start to show
signs of stress, which could ultimately lead to cracking and splitting.
Obviously, FEG wanted its pistols to last for more than 3,000-5,000
rounds, so the design team went to work trying to strengthen the frame,
while not incurring additional weight. It took over a year's worth of
trial and error, but eventually it was discovered that adding 0.1%
titanium to the alloy would allow the frame to withstand repeated and
prolonged firing. The compact design was re-released as the R-61, with
the improved frame. Some sources seem to indicate that the R-61 had a
longer barrel than the RK-59, however this does not appear to be the
case. The R-61 had the same dimensions as its predecessor. It also used
the same magazines. The R-61 is often referred to as the 'police
pistol,' and indeed most were issued to Hungarian law enforcement. Some
though were accepted into military service for ranking officers and
specialized troops who needed a backup sidearm. The R-61 proved to be
durable enough for normal use and FEG continued to offer it until the
(A later production military PA-63)
Witnessingthe success of the R-61, and feeling its Tokarev TT33
pistols were rapidly becoming dated, the Hungarian military also ordered
a pistol from FEG, which was tailored to its own needs. The military
wanted the same lightweight frame, Walther pattern, firing the 9x18mm
round; but wanted it to be somewhat larger. In other-words, while the
police wanted a PPK sized handgun for concealment, the military wanted a
Makarov PM or Walther PP sized sidearm for duty carry. So for the
military, FEG developed the PA-63. The PA had an extended slide, with
3.9" barrel. It was given a more comfortable grip, which was extended
slightly and had a more curved back-strap. Due to the longer grip, the
PA-63's magazine could hold 7 rounds, compared to the R-61's 6. The R-61
could feed from PA magazines, however the reverse was not possible. The
PA also had an extended beaver tail, to protect the shooter from 'hammer
bite.' In all other ways, the two designs were the same and were
produced concurrently. Originally, the PA used the same flat sided grips
as the earlier guns, but later examples featured a slight thumb rest on
the left grip panel to aid with aimed fire. The PA-63 was primarily used
by military officers, though some police did purchase it as well. Most
pistols were produced with a two-tone finish. FEG did make some with
black anodized frames, primarily for commercial export sales. PA-63
production lasted into the late 1980s. It is still issued today to some
Hungarian officers, but it is being slowly phased out of service.
FEG also offered commercial versions of the pistols in the series for
export sales. Many were brought into the USA during the 1980s and 1990s.
Normally, these pistols would have an all-black finish, with a blued
steel slide and anodized alloy frame. A variant of the PA-63 chambered
for the 9mm Short (.380) round was marketed under the name AP-9. Another
version chambered for the 7.65mm (.32) round and with a steel frame was
sold as the AP-7. Commercial versions of the R-61 were also offered as
the SMC-918 in 9x18mm and the SMC-380 in 9mm Short. The SMC has the
distinction of being the smallest handgun ever allowed for importation
into the USA, after the passage of the 1968 GCA. It is tall enough by
0.1" to be considered 'sporting.'
The Radom P-64 & P-83 Pistols:
(An original pattern P-64 made in 1972, with the round hammer)
The next nation to adopt a handgun for the 9x18mm PM Makarov cartridge
was Poland. As with the Hungarians, the Polish were interested in the
cartridge itself, but not the Soviet pistol design that went along with
it. So beginning in the late 1950s, a large and diverse team at the
Radom factory started developing a pistol based around the PM cartridge.
By 1961, a functional prototype of the Polish 9x18mm PM pistol was
entered into extensive military trials and testing. The pistol was often
referred to as the 'CZAK' which was an acronym made by taking the first
letter from the last names of the lead designers of the team from
Radom. The pistol's parts were made entirely of steel, most of which
were machined/milled rather than stamped. It had a traditional
double/single action trigger, with slide mounted decocker safety. So
mechanically it was like other 9x18mm PM pistols. It was smaller than
the Makarov PM, but slightly larger than the FEG R-61. It had an
internal slide hold open, with no external release lever. The magazine
release was located on the heel of the grip, inside a recessed part of
the grip panels. The magazines themselves held 6 rounds and featured a
prominant finger rest. The pistol had a unique safety system. When the
safety was engaged, the trigger was completely disconnected from the
internal lock-work. This system also meant that the pistol's slide could
be racked while the weapon was set to safe. One could not do this with
the Makarov PM.
The pistol was officially accepted into Polish military service as the
Pistolet wz. 1964 in 1965. The P-64 has become known for a very decent
single action trigger pull, but for a truly horrific double action one.
Originally though, this was not the case. Shortly after initial
adoption, the extra heavy hammer spring was incorporated into the
design, after the standard weight spring failed to ignite an
unacceptably high percentage of cartridge primers, during military
testing. The reason for this was that the Polish Army wanted to be able
to use the same 9x18mm ammunition in both their handgun and
submachinegun. The primers on the 9x18mm cartridges were made extra
hard, because if they were not, the PM-63 SMG would occasionally set
them off when the operator did not want it to do so. Thus the P-64 ended
up with a very stiff and heavy double action trigger.
The pistol would remain in production throughout the 1970s. Many were
not satisfied with the design. It was too small for some military
applications (though it was well suited for police use), had a limited
ammunition capacity, was more expensive to produce than the Soviet
Makarov, and of course the heavy double action trigger was not
appreciated by virtually everyone. Throughout the 1970s, several
competing designs were put forth, but none gained traction. The P-64
continued to be the standard sidearm used by most of the Polish military
and police. In the early 1970s, the design was slightly updated with a
larger hammer which was easier to cock. The internal lock-work and safety
system were also tweaked, to make the pistol more drop safe. It would
not be until the mid 1980s, that an improved Polish 9mm Makarov pistol
would finally enter into mass production.
(A Polish military P-83 Wanad manufactured in 1991.)
In the late 1970s, two 9x18mm pistols were being evaluated by the Polish
military: the P-78A and the P-78B. The P-78B, designed primarily by
Ryszard Chelmicki and Marian Gryszkiewicz and named the 'Wanad' (eagle),
would eventually be selected for further development. The Wanad
addressed virtually all of the shortcomings of the P-64. It was larger;
with a longer barrel and slide, and with an extended grip. Thanks to the
new grip, the Makarov PM style single stack magazine could hold 8
cartridges. The Wanad was also more comfortable to operate and fire. It
had a good single action trigger and a smooth double action. Most of the
controls were over-sized and had aggressive ribbing for easier
manipulation. These included: trigger, hammer, and magazine release. The
new pistol featured an external slide release and more convenient
takedown procedure. Rather than a hinged trigger guard like on the P-64,
PA-63, and PM; the Wanad had a latch inside the trigger guard which
could be pulled down and then the slide lifted off the frame. The same
style of decocker safety was used, however a tilting firing pin, much
like the FEG design, insured that accidental discharges would not be an
issue. The Wanad also addressed cost and production concerns. It was
made virtually entirely from steel stampings, rather than forgings.
After years of testing and minor improvements, the P-78B Wanad was
officially adopted as the Pistolet wz. 1983, in 1983. It was
manufactured at the Radom factory, so the quality of workmanship was
very high. Even though the pistol was designed to be inexpensive to
make, it still ended up being a solid, durable, accurate, reliable
firearm. The P-83 became the standard issue sidearm for the Polish
military and for many police agencies. Some police though did keep their
older P-64s, as they appreciated their small size and ability to be
easily concealed. The P-83 is still used today in the Army, but as with
other 9x18mm service pistols, it is slowly being phased out in favor
of a newer design in 9x19mm NATO.
A small number of commercial P-83s were imported into the USA under the
model name 'Eagle.' These pistols were similar to Polish military ones,
but had a spur type hammer and differently shaped trigger guard. A
commercial version of the P-64 was never released in the West though.
the CZ Vz.82 Pistol:
(A military issue Vz.82 manufactured in 1985)
One of the last nations to officially adopt the 9x18mm PM cartridge was
that of Czechoslovakia. It did so under increasing pressure from the
Soviet Union, who very much wanted the nation to conform to the
standards used by the rest of the Warsaw Pact Alliance. Through the
1970s and into the 1980s, the Czech military was primarily equipped with
the 7.62x25mm TT chambered Vz.52 pistol. The pistol was a domestic
design, however it was originally to be chambered for the 9x19mm
Parabellum round. Again, Soviet pressure forced the Czechs to adopt the
TT cartridge in the early 1950s. As for the various Czech police
agencies, they were armed with a range of pistols from the Vz.52, to the
Vz.50 and Vz.70 in 7.65mm. It should be noted that while the Czechs
were reluctant to adopt yet another Soviet caliber, that the Vz.52 proved itself less than ideal only a short time after its adoption. As a
result, the military had been wanting a newer pistol for decades, but
the funding was not available.
Around 1980, work was underway to create a next generation handgun,
capable of firing the PM cartridge. The design team at Ceská zbrojovka
was lead by Augustin Necas, with many other engineers and designers
making important contributions. By 1982, the pistol was ready for field
trials. It was almost immediately adopted as the Vzor.82, however the
design continued to be refined and did not actually enter into full-scale
production until 1984.
Though the Vz.82 was about the same size as the Soviet Makarov, had a
double/single action trigger, and used a straight blowback operating
system; in nearly every other way, it was a totally unique design, even
firing a somewhat unique cartridge. The Vz's barrel was chrome lined
naturally, but what made it unique in the world of communist pistols was
its polygonal rifling. A short time later, Glock would make the rifling
pattern world famous, but CZ used it first in its 9mm PM pistol.
Another interesting fact is that the Vz.82 was the first sidearm to be
adopted by any military with both an ambidextrous magazine release and
manual safety catch. Only the external slide release lever was not
ambidextrous. The pistol had a wide trigger and large hammer spur, which
combined with a smooth double action, and a light single action
trigger, made the pistol comfortable for the operator to fire. Finally,
nearly a decade before Izhevsk's PMM, CZ's pistol fed from 12 round
double stack magazines. To accommodate the larger magazines, the Vz.82
was somewhat thicker than the standard Makarov PM, but in length and
height the two designs are virtually the same.
As to the round designed by Sellier and Bellot to be used in the pistol,
it too was designated simply 9mm (9x18mm) Cartridge Vzor.82. Here
again, a similarity can be observed between Izhevsk's and CZ's efforts.
S&B manufactured the bullet for the Vz.82 cartridge by compressing
iron powder. The bullet was lighter than that commonly used in the PM
cartridge; and it was backed by an increased powder charge. Its
designers claimed the Vz cartridge was up to 20% more powerful than the
standard Soviet loading. Also, due to its construction, the bullet would
fragment upon impact with a solid body, which insured it would not over
penetrate and waste energy. CZ's Vz.82 pistol was designed specifically
to take advantage of the S&B cartridge, however it was still
capable of firing and cycling the standard 9x18mm PM loading.
By the late 1980s, the Vz.82 pistol and cartridge began to see
widespread issuance throughout both the Czech military and police
forces. While its true the initial reasons for adopting the 9x18mm round
came from Russia, as with most all of their firearms, the Czechs took
as much of an independent approach to the new firearm as was
realistically possible for a Warsaw Pact nation to take. In the end, a
handgun that was superior to its predecessors in almost every way was
created. It was more durable and reliable than the Vz.52, while also
being cheaper and easier to mass produce. Compared to the Vz.50/70, the
Vz.82 fired a much more powerful round and had nearly twice the
ammunition capacity. All while not really any more costly or time
consuming to manufacture. CZ also offered a commercial line based on
their military model. It was named CZ-83 by the company and was
virtually the same as the Vz.82, except for different markings and the
lack of a lanyard ring. Also, it had a somewhat smaller trigger guard.
The CZ-83 could be purchased in the original 9x18mm PM caliber, 9x17mm
Short (.380), or even in 7.65mm (.32 Auto in the USA). Magazine
capacities were 12, 13, and 15 rounds respectively for the different
chamberings. The CZ-83 was imported into the USA in limited numbers,
with most chambered for the 9mm Short round.
Obviously, the communist government fell from power just after the
pistol had fully entered into service. With so much time and energy
already dedicated to its development, the new democratic Czech state
decided to keep the Vz.82 in front line service for at least a decade
longer. It is still in service today with some, though others have
traded in their 9x18mm pistols for even newer and more powerful
General Features & Performance For All Pistols;
Operating System: Simple straight (aka direct) blowback
Trigger Type: Double/Single Action
Safety System: Manual safety lever (passive firing pin block found in some models)
Sights: Fixed blade front, drift adjustable notch rear
Optimum Range: 15 to 25 m
Effective Practical Range: Out To 50 m
Cartridge: 9x18mm PM (aka Makarov)
Muzzle velocity: 315 m/s (for standard PM cartridge, from standard barrel length)
305 m/s (for standard PM cartridge, from shorter barrel length)
400 m/s (for S&B Vz.82 cartridge)
430 m/s (for Izhevsk PMM cartridge)
Manufacturer: Izhevsk Mechanical Plant & Tula Arms Factory
(USSR/Russia), Ernst Thaelmann (Germany), Arsenal (Bulgaria), various
Norinco factories (China)
Weight: 730 g (26 oz)
Length: 161.5 mm (6.34 in)
Barrel length: 93.5 mm (3.83 in)
Height: 124 mm (4.9 in)
Width: 29.4 mm (1.16 in)
Magazine Capacity: 8 rds
Manufacturer: Izhevsk Mechanical Plant
Weight: 760 g (27 oz)
Length: 165 mm (6.34 in)
Barrel length: 93.5 mm (3.83 in)
Height: 124 mm (4.9 in) (with lanyard ring)
Width: 38 mm (1.5 in) (can vary depending on grip style)
Magazine Capacity: 12 rds (also 8 rds)
Manufacturer: FEG Smallarms Factory
Weight: 595 g (21.0 oz)
Length: 175 mm (6.9 in)
Barrel length: 100 mm (3.9 in)
Height: 121 mm (4.8 in)
Width: 32 mm (1.26 in) (with flat grip panel)
Magazine Capacity: 7 rds
Manufacturer: FEG Smallarms Factory
Weight: 535 g (19.0 oz)
Length: 158 mm (6.2 in)
Barrel length: 88 mm (3.4 in)
Height: 102 mm (4.1 in)
Width: 32 mm (1.26 in) (with flat grip panel)
Magazine Capacity: 6 rds
Manufacturer: Lucznik Arms Factory, Radom
Weight: 620 g (22 oz)
Length: 160 mm (6.3 in)
Barrel length: 84.6 mm (3.3 in)
Height: 117 mm (4.6 in)
Width: 26 mm (1.05 in)
Magazine Capacity: 6 rds
Manufacturer: Lucznik Arms Factory, Radom
Weight: 730 g (26 oz)
Length: 165 mm (6.5 in)
Barrel length: 90 mm (3.5 in)
Height: 125 mm (4.9 in)
Width: 30 mm (1.2 in)
Magazine Capacity: 8 rds
Manufacturer: Ceská zbrojovka (CZ)
Weight: 800 g (28 oz)
Length: 172 mm (6.8 in)
Barrel length: 97 mm (3.8 in)
Height: 127 mm (5.0 in)
Width: 36 mm (1.4 in)
Magazine Capacity: 12 rds
Importation Of Surplus 9x18mm pistols Into The USA:
In addition to the newly manufactured commercial pistols imported into
the USA primarily by Russia, Hungary, and China; there have been many
waves of surplus military and police guns chambered for the 9x18mm round
brought into the USA. During the 1990s, FEG PA-63s were brought in in
large numbers, as were East German Makarov PMs. The PA-63s began to dry
up around 2002-2004, with the last major import wave in 2006. Originally
they were very affordable at less than $100, but their prices have
slowly climbed since. In the early to mid 1990s, Century imported a
small batch of surplus RK-59 pistols, numbering only about 3,000. These
quickly were bought up by collectors. Due note that an RK should be
treated as a collectable; not a shooter. Some individuals in the USA
have reported firing thousands of rounds through theirs, however the
pistol was rapidly discontinued for a very real reason. Also there are
plenty of other small pistols out there for shooting, why risk damaging a
unique collectable? A few R-61s have also been imported here and there
since the mid 1990s, though the majority were re-barreled by the importer
(or possibly by FEG on request) to fire .380. It was thought that the
more common caliber would make the pistols sell better. As a result,
today R-61s still in the original caliber bring significantly more than
those in .380. All of these pistols will be marked '9mm M' on the slide,
but a re-barreled pistol will have "9mm Short' stamped on the chamber.
As for the DDR PMs, they were commonly available, though at a notably
higher price of $200-$250, until around 2005, with major importation
having ended a year or two earlier.
Around the turn of the millenium, Bulgarian Makarov PMs also hit the
market in large numbers. With these, some Soviet Russian PMs also
'snuck' in. The Bulgarian PM could easily be found in most gun shops in
2000-2002 for under $100, but then importation was halted suddenly.
More recently it has resumed, however the pistols have been over $200
Next to come in were the Radom P-64s, which began to appear in roughly
2002. These pistols have been quite steady for the last decade and their
prices have remained under $200 for the most part. When they first came
in, they were $150, which made them nearly twice the cost of a
In 2005, the first Vz.82 pistols were imported from the Czech Republic.
Two things allowed for their availability. First enough Czech military
and police units had surplussed their pistols to make large scale
importation feasible, and the 1994 AWB sunset in October of 2004.
Without the AWB around, the pistols could be brought in with their
original high-capacity magazines, which made things much easier for the
importers and made the pistols more desirable to civilian shooters. When
they first came in, Vz.82s were $250-$300, so their prices have
actually dropped over the past 7 years. They are still easily found
today, however overseas supplies are starting to get low.
Finally, one of the last surplus 9x18mm pistols to be imported into the
USA was the Radom P-83 Wanad. The first military P-83s were imported in
2009. Prior to this time, true Polish military P-83s were very rare and
commanded a price of $500 and up. Since importation began, their prices
have remained more or less stable at $250, give or take a few bucks.
What is the value of a Makarov in the USA today?
Honestly, as much or as little as people are willing to pay. Still we can rely on a few guidelines....
1) Russian Military - the most valuable PM and lately I've seen some
people asking $750 and up for ones in nice shape with correct
2) Russian Commercial PM (single stack) - While good guns, these do not
command a very high price right now. Say $200-$300 depending on
3) Russian Commercial PM (double stack) - These still do not command a
premium today, but are worth more than the single stacks. $250-$325 with
factory 10 rd mag, $300-$400 with factory 12 rd mag, and $150-$250 with
4) East German PM - because of their generally excellent fit and finish,
these bring good money on today's market. You are looking at $300 for a
rough example, $400 for a good one, and $500 for a near-mint DDR PM.
5) Chinese Norinco Type 59 - Due to their relative rarity, Chinese
Makarovs do bring a decent amount today. They are about on par with the East Germans. $350 for a well used example, to $500 or even more for a
6) Bulgarian Makarov PM - These are among the best values in 9x18 guns.
Though not nearly as cheap as they once were, Bulgie Maks are well made
and authentic military issue. So if you want something just like a true
Soviet Makarov, but are unwilling to pay well over $500 for a damn PM,
look into a Bulgie. They start out at $200 for a rough example and climb
to about $300 for a nice one.
7) Hungarian FEG PA-63 - Once these were about as cheap as a surplus
9x18mm could be, but importation has ended and prices are going up. With
luck, one might still find one for under $200, but it seems like $250
to $350 is a more common asking price range today.
8) Hungarian FEG RK-59 & R-61 - only a few thousands of these
pistols were imported by Century about 20 years ago, so the supply is
very fixed. The RK-59s are valued as collectables, while the R-61s are
good shooters and even CCW pieces. Its hard to find either one in decent
shape for under $300 these days, with $350-$400 being a more
common price for a nice example.
9) Hungarian FEG SMC - SMC - importation has also ended, but more of
these commercial compacts were imported than the original surplus ones.
The SMCs start out at $250 and go up to $350 or so. If you want an FEG
9x18mm that is PPK sized, but can't find a R-61, you should look for an
SMC-918. The two pistols are identical except for markings and the
10) Polish P-64 - these are still available as current surplus, so as a
result can be had for $200 or less right now. Recent reports do seem to
indicate however, that P-64 supplies are getting low.
11) Polish P-83 Wanad - these are also available as current surplus and can be found for between $250 and $300.
12) Czech Vz.82 - once very rare in the USA, these hit the market 7
years ago and are still going strong. They can be found for $200 in
decent to $250 in nice condition.
Magazines & Holsters:
> If a pistol comes with a spare mag, of course that increases its
value. PM mags are common still, as are ones for the P-64, PA-63, and
Vz.82. However, magazines for the P83 are in somewhat limited supply, so
they usually sell for more. The RK-59, R-61, and SMC-918 all accept the
same magazines, and these magazines are uncommon to rare today.
Finally, factory mags for the Russian double stack Makarov are rare and
worth well over $50 for a 10 rounder and 12 rounders can go for as much
as $100. Aftermarket PMM type mags such as Pro-Mag are not at all very
highly thought of though and should probably be avoided if possible.
(2 styles of 8 rd PM magazines)
(P-64 and P-83 Magazines)
(PA-63 and R-61/SMC-918 magazines)
(Both early 2 piece body, and later solid body double stack PMM magazines)
(An earlier production Vz.82 with the milled floorplate)
> Many surplus 9x18mm pistols might come with a military or police
issue holster. Virtually all holsters specifically designed for one of
these pistols and issued by a military, will be of a flap style made of
brown or black leather. The holster will hold a spare magazine and may
or may not hold a cleaning rod too. Most common are the standard Makarov
PM holsters from Bulgaria, East Germany, and Russia. A few types of
holster for the Vz.82 have been imported, including the ambidextrous
military pattern and more traditional police type. Hungarian holsters
for the PA-63 are not exactly common, but can be found with a bit of
looking. The smaller police holsters for the RK-59 and R-61 are rather
rare though. Compact holsters in both black and brown, and with and
without metal loops, have come in for the P-64. More recently, ones for
the P-83 have also appeared. None of these holsters are high-dollar
items, but do add $10-$30 to a pistol's value generally speaking.
Cleaning rods and lanyard ropes are usually considered as bonuses, as
neither are normally worth more than $5 when separated from the rest of
(A standard PM holster made in Bulgaria)
(A Polish military P-64 holster)
(A Hungarian military PA-63 holster)
(A Russian holster designed for the PMM pistol and spare high cap magazine)
Pros & Cons Of The Designs:
Here is a list of some of the advantages and disadvantages of each of
the 9x18 designs talked about in this thread. Perhaps this information
can help someone choose which (if any) 9x18mm is best for them?
1) Makarov PM; designed as a backup self-defense weapon and intended primarily for NCOs and other military personnel.
> Its the original and parts are easy to find, including magazines
> Its all steel construction and simple design make it highly durable and low maintenance.
> It has an external slide release lever.
> It can handle virtually every type and kind of 9x18mm PM ammunition out there.
> The trigger pull in DA is unremarkable to heavy, depending on the individual pistol.
> Some Americans dislike its heel mounted magazine release.
> Though it is rather compact, it is not light by most standards.
2) FEG PA-63; designed to meet requirements set forth by the Hungarian People's Army for a medium sized duty sidearm.
> The alloy frame allows this pistol to be quite light for its size.
> It has a very dependable safety system.
> It has a 1911 style button magazine release, which many prefer.
> Some 9x18mm loadings out there do not cycle reliably in the PA. Especially those with slightly longer bullets.
> It is actually the longest 9x18mm pistol, so not ideal for concealment.
> It does not have a slide release lever.
> Its ammunition capacity is somewhat limited.
3) FEG R-61; Designed expressly as a sidearm for Hungarian police officers.
> This is a very small pistol in all dimensions: length, height, and width.
> This is a very light pistol, especially for one built entirely of metal.
> It has a 1911 style magazine release, again some prefer this.
> Due to its small size and light weight, this pistol can have excessive felt recoil.
> It does not have a slide release lever.
> Its ammunition capacity is quite limited.
> Some replacement parts are not easy to find, including magazines, grips, and springs.
4) Radom P-64; Designed to be used along side the PM-63 SMG and as a backup military sidearm.
> This pistol is very well made with excellent fit and finish.
> It is very compact and easy to conceal.
> Thanks to its all steel construction, it is quite durable.
> The SA trigger is quite good for a 9x18mm pistol.
> The DA trigger is simply the worst I've ever found on a pistol.
> It is quite heavy for its size.
> It is not especially comfortable to fire because of its small grip.
> It does not have a slide release lever.
> It has a heel mounted magazine catch.
> It has the smallest sights found on any 9x18mm; good for holster draw, not so good for aiming.
> These pistols were made with tight chambers, so some ammunition out there will not cycle reliably in them.
> Its ammunition capacity is quite limited.
> Pistols with the original round hammer are rather difficult to cock one handed.
> There are reports of the pistol discharging if dropped onto its
hammer. This is more likely with the original lock-work pattern.
5) Radom P-83; Designed to address multiple complaints made by POlish army officers about the P-64.
> As with most things Radom, it is very well made, even though it is mostly built from stampings.
> Its controls are over-sized for easy manipulation.
> Its trigger pull in both DA and SA is quite nice for a 9x18mm pistol.
> It has an external slide release lever.
> It has a very dependable safety system.
> Its takedown procedure is easier than other 9x18mm pistols.
> Its mostly all stamped construction might not appeal to some.
> It has a heel mounted magazine catch.
> Its ammunition capacity is not particularly impressive for a 1980s pistol.
6) CZ Vz.82; Designed under Soviet pressure and also to replace the mostly disappointing Vz.52.
> Generally speaking, this pistol has the best DA and SA trigger pulls in the 9x18mm world.
> It has the highest ammunition capacity of any of the guns.
> It has both ambidextrous magazine and safety catches.
> It has an external slide release, though it is not ambidextrous.
> It has a large spur hammer for easy one handed manipulation.
> It has the largest sights of any of the 9x18mm pistols, and they normaly are marked with high-visibility paint.
> It has an easier takedown procedure.
> It has a 1911 style thumb safety, that can only be engaged when the hammer is cocked.
> It lacks a decocker, making going from SA to DA with a loaded chamber somewhat risky.
> Its paint type finish is not especially durable and wears off quite easily.
> It is heavier than the other 9x18mm pistols.
> It is also taller and wider than the other pistols, though still reasonably compact.
> It is more mechanically complex than the other 9x18mm pistols,
which makes detailed stripping harder, and could possibly lead to
There is a goodly bit of confusion surrounding these pistols by
civilians in the USA today. Here are some common questions and
Q) Is there such a thing as a Polish, Hungarian, Romanian, or Czech Makarov?
A) No, the only nations to make true Makarov PMs were as listed earlier:
Russia, East Germany (Germany after Unification also), China, and
Bulgaria. All other pistols are unique designs whose parts do not
interchange with those of the real Makarov. The PA-63 and P-64 are no
more 'Makarovs' than a SiG Sauer P220 in .45 ACP is a Colt Model 1911A1.
What links the pistols in this thread is their common caliber. They
can't even share magazines.
Q) Is it Vz.82 or CZ-82, or does it even matter?
A) It is Vz.82 and it does matter as technically CZ never made a pistol
named CZ-82; rather the commercial model was called the CZ-83.
Q) Of the true Makarov pistols, which is the best?
A) Most sources agree that the East German guns consistently have the
nicest fit and finish. Most sources also agree that the Chinese guns
generally have the poorest fit and finish, mostly because of their thin
salt-bluing. Now between Russian and Bulgarian military, neither is
clearly superior. Both nations could make a damn nice pistol, but both
also had their off days. Russian Commercial pistols are generally
thought to have poorer finishes than military pistols though.
Q) Can I fire......?
A) Just stop right there. Only put 9x18mm Makarov PM in a gun marked 9mm
M and .380 in one marked 9mm Short. You absolutely should not fire
9x19mm Parabellum or even 9x18mm Ultra/Police in any of these pistols.
Full stop, end of story, period.
Q) Since they look virtually the same, will Makarov PM and P-83 Wanad magazines interchange?
A) No sorry, though they look the same, they are just dimensionally
different enough that neither magazine will fit in the other pistol. Bad
news for P-83 owners I know.
Q) Are actual Makarov Pm pistols from the different nations/manufacturers parts compatible?
A) Generally speaking yes they are. Russia, Bulgaria, East Germany, and
China all used the same tooling and blueprints to produce their pistols.
Magazines for sure are interchangeable, though there are slight
differences in them from time to time.
Q) Can I (legally) remove the thumb rest target grips from my Bulgarian or East German Makarov?
A) Yes, it is not a violation of any Federal law to remove those grips
and install original military grips. The thumb rest grips were added to
give the pistol enough 'points' for importation under the 1968 GCA, but
once the pistol is in the USA and in private hands, it doesn't matter.
Q) Can I erase/buff out the ugly import marking on my pistol?
A) Absolutely not. It is a Federal crime to deface or obscure an importer's marking, sorry.
Q) What can I do to make the import mark less noticeable and apparent?
A) It is acceptable and not forbidden to colour the marking, say with a
product such as Cold Blue. It helps a goodly bit, or so I am told.
Q) Are replacement springs from makers such as Wolf a good idea?
A) If you plan to fire your 9x18mm frequently, they are a great idea.
Just be sure to get the exact spring set for your pistol. I just mean,
PA-63s need PA-63 springs and springs designed specifically for the
Makarov PM should not be installed or used in any other model.
Q) Are any of these surplus 9x18mm pistols good conceal & carry pieces?
A) Honestly? No not really. True some are quite small and they do pack a
decent punch, but just remember you have a firearm that was manufactured
as many as 50 years ago by a communist factory. These pistols were
designed for military use, not civilian carry. Also many saw decades of
moderate to heavy use and handling. In other words, I am just not sure
its wise to trust ones life to a well used pistol with an unknown past.
Back when 9x18mms were under $100, alright maybe they were a decent
alternative for someone who really couldn't afored anything better.
Today though they are over $200 and for just a bit more a person can
purchase a factory new pistol with warrenty, designed specifically for
modern CCW duty. Just my 2 cents of course, but think about it.
Q) Which 9x18mm Pistols are considered C&R by the BATF?
A) Original Russian military, East German military, Polish P-64, and
Czech military Vz.82s. The Bulgarian and Chinese PMs are not C&R.
Neither are the Hungarian PA-63, R-61, SMC-918, or the P-83 Wanad.
Q) Do you realise its insane to have the Vz.82 C&R, but not the PA-63 or Bulgie PM?
A) Yes I sure do, but its also kind of awesome if you have a C&R license and want a Vz.82.
Q) In all of this boringly and pointlessly long post, about a pistol i
hardly care about; you barely talk about how these shoot. How accurate
are each of the pistols and how are the sights?
A) Hell if i really know, why don't you ask someone with eyes?
Q) Why do you like the Makarov and the other 9x18mm pistols so much? They seem kind of plain and boring to me.
A) I am interested in Russian and Cold War history. I am interested in
firearms. I like how they feel and shoot...Alright, ok the truth is when
i discovered i loved guns I was a broke ass college sophomore. I
couldn't really afford anything even half way nice, but thanks to great
luck, I discovered guns right in the middle of the 'Golden Age' of
Milsurp (1990-2005 CA) and several 9x18mm pistols were on the market at
the time for less than what most people spend today to fill up their gas
tanks twice (or once if you drive something really huge). So every few
months, i'd save up and go to a local shop that specialized in milsurp
and military firearms and see what they had for under $100, or $200 if I'd had a birthday recently. So several of my pistols have followed me
around for over a decade and have a goodly bit of personal value. That
and old communist firearms really are neat.
The pistols pictured in this write-up are mine, except for the 4
pictures from ModernFirearms. The oldest I've had for 12 years; the
newest for just a week. I feel my collection is complete, though I'd not
say no to a Soviet PM or RK-59.
I am sure I
have made some mistakes too as most of what is above came from my own
demented mind, with some names, dates, and measurements taken from
Wikipedia and other sites. Still, i think the read (did you actually
read it? you better have done, i spent hours typing it) gives a
respectable enough overview of the Makarov PM and other pistols based
around its 9mm PM cartridge.
Seriously though, for those of you who did read through and are posting
to contribute your own information, pictures, or stories; thank you. I
do this because i enjoy it, but it is nice to know my energies haven't
been wasted. It would be nice to see a rekindling of interest for the
Makarov too. After all, thousands upon thousands of these pistols are in
the USA today, with still more being imported right now. Also the
ammunition is actually pretty easy to find, and quite inexpensive to
boot. Just saying you could do worse than to get a 9x18mm as your next